Embroidered Clothing is Better

Say, did you know that it’s National Embroidery Month?

I’m guessing 100 hours on embroidering this dress.

No, me either. Which is tragic. I feel like I’ve wasted ten days of potential embroidery bliss through my careless ignorance. Not to say that I haven’t been embroidering–I have–but I didn’t know that I had the perfect opportunity to torment you all with embroidery talk!

I don’t remember when I started embroidering. I have half-completed embroidery projects around from when I was in elementary school, so it’s apparently been for at least 30 years; but I wouldn’t consider myself to be an expert. There are so many skills, stitches and techniques to master in embroidery that I will never get to that level.

I will never, ever be this good. Amazing.

It’s got a bit of a fusty reputation, too, much like sewing had in the last decade or so: it’s for old women, right? Making dustcatchers with bible verses to give as Christmas presents. Though there is nothing wrong with this, and the ageism and sexism in the assumption is problematic, it’s also completely not true. Lots of people, both men and women and of all ages–including this program for male prisoners in the UK–embroider; it’s not just for pillow covers and wall hangings; and if you want to put your favourite Walking Dead or Friends quote on your work, well, nothing’s stopping you.

Right? Now there’s a way to combine needlework and power tools!

But there’s no getting around that hand embroidery, unlike machine sewing, really is something that takes time, practice and effort to master. Don’t get snippy: you can make a knit t-shirt in an afternoon, and it will be perfectly wearable; you can master the techniques required to make a gathered skirt by machine in a day, as many beginners classes prove; but it may take you a year of practicing your stitches before you are good enough to embroider that t-shirt or skirt, and when you do, it will probably take you a week of active stitching time to actually do it. I hand-embroidered a work bag a few years back; it took 40 hours to make the bag from start to finish, and at least half of that was just the embroidery. Totally worth it, though.

This is why our clothes are no longer embroidered. Fast fashion and mass production rely on things that are replicable by machine and can be completed in a short enough time that the costs are still low. Hand embroidery does not fit in that business model. I think that our decades’ long experience with mass produced fashion has conditioned our eyes to see it as something somehow odd, fussy, irrelevant, or not-modern. As something we’ve outgrown. But frankly, if you’re already invested in making your own clothes, then you have already mostly rejected mass produced clothing, and you may as well go all the way. Haute couture still recognizes that well-completed hand-embroidery elevates a garment, adds a loveliness that cannot be replicated by machine embroidery or by printed fabric.

Also, embroidery has an incredibly long and surprisingly functional history. Smocking, for example, is something now associated with heirloom dresses made for little girls; but historically, it was used on workers’ clothing to add stretch to woven fabrics. Sashiko embroidery was first developed in Japan to reinforce areas of wear on clothing, or at stress points to prevent wear.

Some embroidery was of course always entirely decorative, and speaks to me of the need for personal decoration built deep within human nature.

Sioux dress w/ fully beaded yoke, from Wikipedia.

Aren’t these incredible? Imagine the dedication and skill it would take, not to mention the time, to produce something so beautiful. Imagine the need to make beautiful things that would have encouraged people to develop those technologies and skills in the first place!

Our clothing is no longer embroidered by hand because our clothing today is cheap, and hand embroidery is not cheap. Clothing today is meant to be disposable; if it wears out, if the colours bleed, if it fades, pitch it. Hand embroidery is not disposable; if done well, it will last for centuries.

I can understand why new sewers would be aiming for the quality of off-the-rack clothes: they represent the lowest common denominator of acceptable clothing in public, right? The seams are straight, the hems are even, things are pressed. And then fitting is the next natural skill to tackle, making clothes that are better than off-the-rack because the fit has been perfected for the body it goes on.

But what then? Do you just jump on a treadmill of cranking out endless repetitions of perfectly fitting garments that look like off-the-rack, but better fitted? End up with a closet just as full as the worst fast-fashion junkie’s? Is mimicking disposable fashion the end of the line in sewing skills development?

Of course not. Unless you really just want 30 identical boring knit t-shirts, so you can wear a different one every day for a month. But then you’ve made your thirty identical boring knit t-shirts, and then what?

If you get to that point, and you’re looking for a way to slow down in your clothing production, add more visible hand-made details, make something that will last and that does not look in any way like it came from a mall–in a good way–might I suggest embroidery? It is the last stage in handmade couture clothing, Dear Readers.

~~~~~

tl/dr: I’ll be talking about embroidery a lot over the next couple of weeks. You’ve been warned.

~~~~~

All of the clothing images, with the exception of the Sioux dress, are haute couture clothing designs from runway shows. And they’re all a bit over-the-top and decadent. But I hope they made the point that our clothing today isn’t embroidered, not because it’s old-fashioned or out-of-date or inherently unattractive, but because it costs serious time and dedication.

11 thoughts on “Embroidered Clothing is Better”

  1. Thanks for this post, it really struck a chord with me. Lately I’ve been thinking how embroidery is craft which doesn’t have a real function, you can’t embroider something to serve a different purpose, you just embroider. It comes off as extravagant in a minimalist world. But your argument makes sense, things which take time matter.

  2. I’ve been thinking a lot about this recently too, particularly since I read an article that was titled something like ‘ten ways to make your homemade clothes look professional’. It contained lots of useful tips about pressing and seam lengths etc, but also mentioned not using hand sewing as RTW clothes wouldn’t. It gave me pause for thought but I concluded that while I don’t want my clothes to look badly made I am very happy for them to look handmade and will endeavour to hand finish or embroider any garment where it will add to but not distract from the finish. My embroidery skills aren’t up to much yet though!

    1. It doesn’t make a lot of sense, does it? Particularly when you consider that the world’s most expensive clothing, and the clothing that sets the trends for what we all wear, is still sewn by hand.

  3. Oh I love embroidery! However I fear that my skills are really not up to that kind of beautiful detail. Maybe I should just take the leap anyways (that’s what I did with sewing!)

    1. Absolutely!

      There’s a couple of things you can try, too, to make the jump a bit easier:

      1. Waste canvas. Baste it on to a regular fabric and it gives you a nice removable grid for even stitching.
      2. Cross stitching and blackwork work really well for that–again, much easier to get nice, even stitches with a fun design
      3. And using a monochromatic palette will help too (so white stitching on white fabric, or red on red, or what have you). Then any little glitches won’t be so obvious, and if you remove any stitches, they won’t leave a mark.

      Just some ideas. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s